Skip to content

David Pearce Music Reviews

Time Well Spent

Have you ever regretted reading a book — which one and why?

There have been a number of books I have disliked, a few I have actually been profoundly irritated by – a ‘sequel’ to A Christmas Carol comes immediately to mind – and some that I ploughed through in case I ended up liking it but didn’t. However, I have not at any time regretted reading a book. I don’t see why you would.

Reading a book, even one you don’t like, is always time well spent if only to mark your card for particular authors you won’t read again. There have been a few books I have thoroughly disliked but I have read other books in that style or even by that author and really enjoyed them. The bad sequels have sent me back to the original books with new appreciation for their excellence. The genres that I haven’t liked have become clear and I have avoided them afterwards. In every book, even the least appreciated, there is something to be gained. It might be a sentence that is particularly good, an image that sticks in your mind or even a character whose physical description you enjoy.

So, while there are plenty of books that are not for me, I can never regret reading a single one of them. In a country where 40% of people never read a book I am already immeasurably richer in my own life even reading a bad book. Not reading a book at all would be the real regret.

The Start of the Holiday?!

What’s the best and worst airport you’ve been to?

My family seem to love airports. They get excited when they arrive because it’s the start of the holiday. This baffles me. To me airports are soulless places that exist only to move groups of people from one place to another, usually via an extremely long walk in an atmosphere that ranges from depressing attempts by staff and travellers to ‘have fun’ to the usually offhand and sometimes downright rude attitude displayed by the security staff. In the airport you exist only as a cash cow, where overpriced shops and restaurants compete to reduce the amount of spending money you have on holiday. I get told off for not enjoying myself but I don’t see how you can in a kind of cross between a cattle market and purgatory! The holiday starts only when you get to the hotel for me.

Asian airports tend to try to make the experience of waiting for your plane relatively pleasant with Singapore and Kuala Lumpur being the standouts. Their restaurants are excellent, the shops are fascinating and reasonably priced and the family travelling together are actually cared about with great little play areas. Add to that green spaces and even art galleries and you have airports that make an effort.

The worst airport by a country mile is Newark New Jersey. The food is routinely awful, ludicrously overpriced and served as quickly and in as perfunctory manner as possible. Then you get to security which is unpleasant even by the usual standards of the profession.  They all seem to be annoyed that they aren’t in the FBI and therefore are unable to attack you! In all seriousness, there is an atmosphere in that airport that seems to put everyone on edge. I don’t intend to ever go to the US again, but if I did I would avoid Newark like the plague.

It would be so good if someone could temporarily lobotomise me whilst I am in the airport and re-engage my thinking faculties when I get to my hotel at the other end!!

The Backstory

What’s the most annoying trope in books or movies?

Funnily enough I was thinking about this yesterday. I passed a charity shop and in the window was a puzzle featuring Disney villains. It took me back to the days when a villain was bad, it was as simple as that. Although I hate Westerns, having been forced to watch them endlessly as a child, the heroes and villains were clearly differentiated and the villains did bad things because they were bad people, not because they were mistreated as children or they had some sort of trauma. I don’t want to understand villains in books, movies or real life, I want to see them defeated and punished for their crimes.

In The Aristocats, for example, Edgar the Butler was greedy and was horrified that his employer was going to leave everything to her cats and then to him once the cats were gone. Now, fair enough, I would have been very annoyed as well if my employer just overlooked all my services and given her money to someone undeserving in my eyes. (Actually, that’s what happens anyway if I am the employee and the actual cats are replaced by Fat Cats but that’s a blog for another day!) However, we didn’t need a long involved backstory with Edgar as a child struggling with poverty or as a young man being thrown out of his house because he couldn’t pay the rent. He was bad, he did bad things, no further explanation necessary.

In the Narnia books, Jadis the White Witch was a truly evil character. She destroyed her own world and everything in it to get the better of her sister. She found her way into Narnia and started using dark magic and killing, or turning to stone, those who defied her. She did this because she was an evil person, no other reason. If it turned out she was badly treated by the rest of the Charn Royal Family that would have diluted her evil and made it commonplace. The fact that she was irredeemably evil gives the narrative its power.

So, stop explaining villains. Writers think it makes their stories multi layered and interesting. It doesn’t, it just makes them dull and far less effective. Bad things are done by bad people. Let’s go back to those days so we can just enjoy their comeuppance.

An Unappealing Prospect

If you could relive one year of your life, which one would it be?

This is similar to a recent daily prompt but supersized to ask about a whole year. So, let’s look at the concept in detail to examine how flawed it actually is.

There are three possibilities. One, you relive it from the inside as it happened only with the knowledge of what happens afterwards. How bad would that be? You could see your mistakes, know what they lead to but be compelled to make those mistakes once more. It would be like a horror story. Whichever year you were forced to relive you would see so many stupid decisions and so many difficulties that you created for yourself or that others created for you. It would be like watching a slow motion car crash.

Two, you relive it but you have the opportunity to change what you did. OK, that’s superficially appealing, but what do you change and how do you change it? You could change something short term that has a massive long term impact because you didn’t think it through properly. You could come back to the modern day and find that it’s completely changed. Read the Butterfly Effect short story to see how that works or watch Back to the Future! You could end up completely ruining what you have.

Three, you relive it as a spectator. You just watch it unfold from the outside this time. Again, you can’t change anything and you have to watch all the mistakes and all the arguments and problems without being able to do anything about them. It would be the world’s most frustrating film!

On balance it’s far better to live life forwards. I will leave the dangerous or sterile or maddening process of reliving your life to others!

The World of Work 1983 style – a favourite post

On September 5, 1983 I entered the world of work for the first time, starting a career that has had more twists and turns than most! 40 years on, I thought it might be interesting to look back to what the office looked like in the analogue days of the early 80s. Now, this is […]

The World of Work 1983 style

This was written three years ago today and it is, I think, one of my best pieces of writing. Please click on the link and if you agree please comment on the original post or on this one. It’s certainly good enough to earn a much bigger audience. Whether you were around in 1983 or not, this is personal and social history par excellence.